This 24 year old sounds like me when I was that age. Utterly stupid with money and budgeting! Responsible lending is one thing, but you also require a responsible borrower. His entire salary is spent paying debt. Ridiculous. I have a love hate with Money Saving Expert. This reminds me back when I was in car finance, Martin Smug Lewis went on air waxing lyrical about miss sold payment protection insurance and how you could claim back. The nature of the claim was so broad that every man and his dog were claiming to of been " miss sold". People who had completed their finance deal along with being fully covered for that duration would claim they were miss sold without evidence other then signing the document. It came down to sheer hear say " I never asked for it but got given it" (even though it shows you on the contract and the cost shown). There were a few genuine cases however. Such as the applicant not being eligible for PPI to begin with due to employment/age etc. These of course could be evidenced and backed up.